A user checking out one of these URLs does not want to filter only local post on that instance.

On all instances, this url should mean “show me all /c/piracy on all federated instances”

If you really mean /c/piracy only on that instance, then add something to the url.

The current convention breaks the most important aspect of federation and makes its vestigial appendage.

The current way has user asking question /c/piracy, but on which instance ?

So now they’ll all join the same instance . You wouldn’t post anywhere else since no one would every see it.

It’s a recipe for centralization.

I think this is obvious to most users, were deal with “voat with extra steps” here

  • pe1uca@lemmy.pe1uca.devEnglish
    6·
    2 years ago

    It’s the same as in reddit, you can find r/unpopularopinion and r/TrueUnpopularOpinion, or off my chest, or shower thoughts (with the UL one).
    It’d be like asking those communities should only have one feed.
    Similarly here you can have !piracy@lemmy.ml and !piracy@lemmy.world and you’d have to decide which one is more aligned with your idea of what the community should be.
    And if you don’t like it, then you can create a new community in another instance without having to fight for the same name (I could create one in my instance like !piracy@lemmy.pe1uca.dev)

    • interdimensionalmeme@lemmy.mlOPEnglish
      02·
      2 years ago

      And if you post in piracy@lemmy.pe1uca.dev nobody will ever see it because they can only see, by default, what is on https://lemmy.theirinstance.com/c/piracy

      This IS the problem. It makes it nonsensical not to find the biggest community and post there. And second biggest gets the rejects, likes /r/truepiracy and the rest of the long tail will never be read by anyone, user who post there are probably just confused think that lemmy is not centralized

      • Arcaneslime@lemmy.mlEnglish
        7·
        1 year ago

        …all communities named “piracy” are not the same, the full community name technically includes the instance, they are each their own “subreddit.” You could subscribe to all of them if you wish, or to just “the largest one,” but you can think of them as say “lemmyworldpiracy” and “beehawpiracy” and so on, they are just different communities.

        It’d be like if two separate 15yo kids ran a fan page for their favorite anime character and expecting them to be identical simply because they are both about Goku, they’re just different “sites” by different people, they just aren’t the same thing simply because they’re about the same topic.

      • pe1uca@lemmy.pe1uca.devEnglish
        2·
        1 year ago

        Again, it’s the same in reddit, if you create a new sub no one can see it because reddit doesn’t share what new communities there are, they’re hidden from the search unless you know the exact name or until they have enough activity, but it’s a cycle where you can’t have enough activity because it doesn’t appear in searches.
        The answer in both, reddit and lemmy, is crossposting, you need to promote your new community with good content.
        Or sharing it in communities like !wowthislemmyexists@lemmy.ca or !lemmy411@lemmy.ca
        There’s also this site, tho I don’t know how it gets populated https://browse.feddit.de/