yet another transfem programmer from berlin

I use PGP, here’s my signature

  • 0 Posts
  • 1 Comment
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 1st, 2023

help-circle
  • A few points:

    1. you should (strictly) prefer std::scoped_lock over std::lock_guard.
    2. your scope locked takes an std::mutex, not a map (ie in its constructor)
    3. the lambda passed to foo is called a completion handler; one way to thread a bunch of (related) handlers without needing explicit locks is to use so-called strands. As long as all the operations which have to be performed serially are coroutines, spawned within strand in question, you can actually have a thread pool of executors running, and asio will take care of all the locking complexity for you.
    4. you’re using p in the block as a whole, and within the completion handler, so be aware that the p outside has to be well-defined, and that the interior one (in the lambda) shadows the outer one. (I’m a fan of shadowing, btw, the company I used to have lint settings which yelled when shadowing happens, but for me it’s one of the features I want, because it leads to more concise, uniform, clear names – and that in turn is because shadowing allows them to be reused, but in the specific context… anyyyyway)
    5. modern C++ tends to favour async style code. Instead of passing a completion handler to foo, you make foo an awaitable functor which co_yields an index (p, above), one which we can co_await as in:
      // note: the below has to run in a coroutine 
      ...
      my_map[q].insert(10); // renamed outer p to q to avoid collision now that async-style leaves p in the same scope as outer code!
      const auto& p = co_await foo(bar1);
      // use p
      
    6. If you want to do 5 on existing code, follow the guidelines here to wrap legacy callback code into something that works with C++20 awaitables.
    7. If I may be so bold, you’re describing something intrinsically async, so you may want to consider using boost::asio, then you get access to all this.
    8. and nowadays, all this is dead easy to install using conan