Whether you’re really passionate about RPC, MQTT, Matrix or wayland, tell us more about the protocols or open standards you have strong opinions on!

  • vort3@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    21
    ·
    6 months ago

    Others have said already, but XMPP and RSS. Also, nobody mentioned NNTP yet.

    I wish everything was accessible by NNTP and we had better NNTP clients. NNTP is like RSS but for forums (so, Lemmy, Reddit, or anything where you could reply to posts). Download for offline reading, read in your client, define your own formatting, sorting, filtering, your client, your rules.

    If Lemmy was accessible via NNTP, I could just download all posts and comments I’m interested in and reply to them without any connection, and my replies would get synced with the server later when I connect to WiFi or something.

    • vort3@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      9
      ·
      6 months ago

      Probably it would be better to edit my comment, but I’ll go with a reply to myself.

      To all fans of RSS: there’s this service called FeedBase that is essentially a RSS to NNTP gate. You add your RSS feed to that and it becomes a newsgroup on their server, and you can subscribe to it using any NNTP client. New articles appear as new posts in that newsgroup and you can post your own replies to them. So, you get RSS but with discussions or comments.

      https://feedbase.org/

      If you try this, let me know what RSS feeds you’re reading, so we could read the articles together and have some discussion there!

      P.S. This comment is not an ad. I genuinely love feedbase and use that myself.

    • crank@beehaw.org
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      6
      ·
      6 months ago

      Back in the day I was a big Usenet fan. What’s the modern solution to the spam issue? At the time, folk wisdom was that the demise was being caused by spam, and that due to the nature of the protocol it was somehwhat unsolveable.

      I also wonder to what extent activity pub is the barrier to offline use? For reddit, the Slide client had offline reading and iirc posting. I have been disappointed it isn’t available for Lemmy. My guess has been it simply isn’t a priority for the devs. Maybe eventually we will get it.

      I think it would be cool if RSS got put into Lemmy clients. Example you could make a unified inbox for all accounts by automatically getting the private RSS for incoming messages for all logged in accounts. I have manually set this up a couple of times but its tedious. Completely lacks smoothness when it comes to clicking a link, replying etc. But a client could add a little finesse to fix that.

      • vort3@lemmy.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        6 months ago

        True, Lemmy (and activitypub in general) could integrate RSS and also be accessible via NNTP.

        Or at least add some functionality for offline reading/posting. It’s just not a priority for devs now.

        About spam, most of spam was coming from Google groups and since Google unpeered from Usenet, there is no spam.

    • Natanael@slrpnk.net
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      6 months ago

      Content addressable protocols are better for asynchronous use. I’d like to see a proper bluesky atprotocol fork with “post lexicons” properly adapted for forums, they’re built on top of content addressing and public key based account IDs along with 3rd party moderation tooling support integrated and custom 3rd party feeds/views.